The FTC's fake review rule: what local businesses need to stop doing
Since October 2024, fake and incentivized reviews can cost a business civil penalties per violation. Here's what the rule covers and how to grow reviews without breaking it.
Ask three agencies what SEO costs and you'll get three answers that look like they describe different industries. They often do. "SEO" covers everything from a monthly rank report to a full program of technical work, content and digital PR. Before you compare prices, you need to compare what each price buys.
The numbers
The most widely cited benchmark is Ahrefs' pricing survey of 439 SEO providers, updated in 2026. It found an average agency retainer of about $3,209 a month. The same survey shows why the average misleads: the single most common monthly retainer band was $501 to $1,000, chosen by about one provider in five.
So the market isn't a bell curve. There's a large cluster of low-cost local packages and a long tail of larger programs pulling the average up. Prices are also moving: SE Ranking's 2026 survey of 260 agencies found that a majority planned to raise rates this year, largely because optimizing for AI search now sits alongside traditional rankings.
Why quotes vary so much
- Market scope. Ranking a plumber in one city is a different job from ranking a software company nationally.
- Technical debt. A clean ten-page site needs less work than a five-year-old site with broken redirects and duplicate pages.
- Competition. Legal, finance and insurance keywords are expensive to win because competitors have invested for years.
- Content volume. Two articles a month and eight articles a month are not the same retainer.
- Links. Earning links from relevant, reputable sites takes outreach time, and that time costs money.
What a real retainer includes
Whatever the price, a retainer worth paying for does four things every month:
- Fixes technical issues in priority order: crawling, indexation, speed and structured data.
- Publishes or improves pages mapped to specific keywords with buying intent.
- Builds authority through links and mentions from sites your buyers and Google trust.
- Reports on outcomes: organic leads and revenue first, rankings second.
If a proposal can't tell you what will be done in month one, month two and month three, you're buying a subscription to a report, not SEO.
Red flags
- Guaranteed rankings. Nobody controls Google. A guarantee means the agency either picked keywords nobody searches or plans to take risks with your site.
- Link packages sold by the hundred. Cheap links in bulk usually come from networks Google discounts or penalizes.
- No access to your accounts. Your analytics, Search Console and content should stay in your name.
- Reporting that stops at rankings. If nobody connects rankings to enquiries, nobody is accountable for them.
How we price it
We don't sell SEO off a menu. Every engagement starts with a free audit of your site, your competitors and the keywords that matter, and the quote is built from what that audit finds. The proposal lists exactly what gets done each month, and the first three months are a fixed term because that's roughly how long it takes to see real movement. After that, it's month to month.